Diets in Review - Find the Right Diet for You
module top

HCG Diet: Look Elsewhere for Weight Loss

Retweet

You won’t see me promoting quick fixes or fad diets anytime soon. But every once in awhile something comes along that seems so dangerous I have to call it out. That’s why I’m going to help reveal the truth behind the HCG diet.hcg injections

What it is: HCG (human chorionic gonadotropin) is a hormone produced during pregnancy by the cells that form the placenta. This hormone is detected in the blood around 11 days after conception; it is detected in the urine around 12-14 days after conception. While it is most commonly associated with pregnancy, it is present in both genders.

What it does in the body: HCG signals the hypothalamus (area of the brain that affects metabolism) to mobilize fat stores. In pregnancy, this helps the body bring nutrients into the placenta, fueling the fetus with the energy to grow.

The weight loss claim: The HCG diet (using daily hcg injections) will help you lose 1-3 pounds per day.  The HCG-diet combines the daily injections with a very low-calorie diet (500 calories per day).

500-calories per day is severely restrictive! In fact, it is not enough calories to support normal brain function. Your body will compensate by using stores of glycogen, protein (muscle) and some fat, which lowers your resting metabolism. Before you can lose true weight, you will be so irritable, lightheaded, and cranky that you’ll reach for whatever food you can get your hands on and have a field day.

Scientific evidence: There is no scientific evidence supporting HCG injections as a weight loss strategy. In addition, these injections have not been approved by the FDA for use in weight loss. In fact, since 1975 the FDA has required all marketing and advertising of HCG to state the following: “HCG has not been demonstrated to be effective adjunctive therapy in the treatment of obesity. There is no substantial evidence that it increases weight loss beyond that resulting from caloric restriction, that it causes a more attractive or ‘normal’ distribution of fat, or that it decreases the hunger and discomfort associated with calorie-restricted diets.”

“HCG is a hormone extracted from urine of pregnant women. It is approved by FDA for treatment of certain problems of the male reproductive system and in stimulating ovulation in women who have had difficulty becoming pregnant. No evidence has been presented, however, to substantiate claims for HCG as a weight-loss aid.” via the FDAno symbol

HCG ban: The hormone was recently added to the list of “banned substances” in Major League Baseball, as it was becoming increasingly popular among steroid users. Athletes turned to this, among other “performance enhancing drugs” because it “mitigates the side effects of ending a cycle of steroids.”

Negative side effects: The common side effects include headaches, mood swings, depression, blood clots, confusion, and dizziness. Some women also develop a condition called Ovarian Hyperstimulation Syndrome (OHSS); symptoms of this include pelvic pain, swelling of the hands and legs, stomach pain, weight gain, shortness of breath, diarrhea, vomiting/nausea, and/or urinating less than normal.

Remember, if it sounds too good to be true, it usually is. Weight loss is hard work and it won’t come in a potion, pill, or injection. The most “dangerous” thing you should be doing to your body is trying a new exercise that intimidates you like rock climbing or completing a marathon.

Sources:

Banned in MLB
HCG Side Effects
FDA
CalorieLab : “Weight loss is hard, and human pregnancy hormone won’t change that”
Associated Content : “HCG Marketed by convicted fraud, Kevin Trudeau”
Diet Scam Watch : “HCG Worthless as a weight-loss aid”


Advertisement


> Leave Feedback

User Feedback

(Page 1 of 1)

cathy

Comment

Where can I purchase this product. posted Nov 19th, 2009 1:46 pm


sus

Comment

I am on the diet an have loss so far 25 pounds in 3 weeks,I'm doing an 800 calorie diet with it. I want to know where i can get it online why a quick delivery time to USA. posted Nov 19th, 2009 11:41 am


clytlesp

Thumbs Down

Rebecca,

As you can see you got a lot of people riled. It's good to raise a red flag, but hCG dieters will tell you how well the diet works.

The advice to run a marathon is what got to me. As a former runner and one time marathoner, I would warn anyone not to run. Running more than a half hour makes your body release fat into the blood for fuel. When you eat again, your body has to restore that fat.

When you finally get injured by running too much (you always end up injured) your body is a fat making machine.

Eating fat doesn't make you fat. Carbohydrates up insulin levels and that drives fat storage. It's all in Gary Taubes' book "Good Calories, Bad Calories."

Since it flies in the face of everything we think we know about weight loss, most diet "gurus' dismiss Taubes' conclusion that exercise makes us hungry it and doesn't help us lose weight.

And to all a healthy weight,

Chris Lytle, Director of Anger Management, The Zola Diet posted Nov 18th, 2009 6:29 pm Profile send message  Message


userfile
LeahStorm

Comment

Ann - telling people not to be stupid is rude, and not going to get people to listen to your points. Which, by the way are clearly not backed up with any statistics or studies. How many people on any forums, blogs or in medical studies have actually had DVT or PE, or OHSS? When you can back up your statements and become polite to the people on this forum, feel free to post again. Until then, keep your rude, uninformed comments to yourself.

AMBER - Good for you !! I lost 16 pounds in 23 days myself! I'm going for round 2 in January.

To those wondering where to get HCG. It is mostly found in weight loss clinics in most cities. The pharmacy cost for it is around $50, but expect to pay a retail of $250 or more. If you pay more, be sure it includes an exam, a full workup with blood tests, etc. and are getting weekly care from the doctor.

I don't recommend buying it on the internet, because who knows what it is. How could you even test it? Find a dr or clinic.

Leah posted Nov 17th, 2009 10:36 pm Profile send message  Message


Amber

Thumbs Up

Hello,
My name is Amber & I have been on the HCG diet for 2 months & I have lost 58 pounds!!! I am 20 years old & not very different from all of my other friends we eat the same & are all active. The reason I took the step to try HCG is because of my father he has High blood pressure & diabetes. I have always been scared I would develop both of these because I get a lot from my dad but now I am more confident & let me tell you I am 100% more happy with myself as a person not that I wasn't happy before but life is really starting to fall into place :) posted Nov 15th, 2009 9:59 pm


kjlewis

Comment

I have restarted the HCG today. My company has left. No bad side effects yet. I will visit my Dr. on Tuesday for the B12 shot. Hopefully, the migraines will not be an issue this time around. I will keep you posted and thanks for the advice about the water intake! posted Nov 14th, 2009 11:01 pm


samar

Comment

Where are you all getting you HGC from?
posted Nov 14th, 2009 9:27 am


samar

Thumbs Up

Where are you all getting you HGC from?
please i want it posted Nov 14th, 2009 9:21 am


PB~

Thumbs Down

OMG. I have lost 40 pounds using hCG under my doctor's guidance. My cholesterol level is in the normal range, trigylcerides are normal, I have NO pain in my joints anymore, I'm sleeping through the night for the first time in over 27 years, and I'm maintaining my weight easily after following the strict stabilization phase and then reintroducing starches and sugars carefully and slowly.

The United States needs to come out of the dark ages. This diet has been used in Europe for over 50 years with life-saving success. posted Nov 13th, 2009 1:23 pm


Ann

Thumbs Up

Blood clots-they can cause deep vein thrombosis, pulmonary embolisms, which can break off and cause a stroke or DEATH.
Don't be stupid.

Honestly I notice that everyone states "people don't understand weight issues and we can't lose weight with our metabolisms."

I worked in bariatrics and medicine for years, and honestly there are such RARE conditions and genetics that truly cause such issues.

Many make excuses and compensations for their weight, and although claim to be taking action, few actually take the time to learn proper nutrition and exercise.

Isn't it ironic that those who eat well and exercise ARE NOT OVERWEIGHT?

Losing rapids amounts of weight at a time make you lose massive amounts of muscle, including cardiac muscle which can create CONGESTIVE HEART FAILURE??

EAT YOUR VEGGIES! GET OFF THE COUCH! MOVE! AVOID THESE DANGEROUS CRASH DIETS! posted Nov 10th, 2009 8:46 pm


cac4me

Comment

Great News to hear LeahStorm on your weight loss thus far. I too am on my first round and into my 2nd wk. I am paying close to 300 but this does include blood wk, wkly B12 and weekly Dr. visits. I don't have any regrets thus far. As to the post by kjlewis . I will tell u that I did suffer w/a migraine but this was due to an overload of "acandy". I had the worst Migraine ever. However, I have NOT had another one since that day. I will say that when u consume the recommended water. This helps as well. My Dr. recommended at least 2QTs. Now this is alot of water, but it is well worth it. I was also recommended to try the Tea4life, which is a cleanser. I just purchased this on Nov 6th. It actually taste pretty good.

As for the post by beth green. On the question about "blood clots". I read that as well and don't have a history with these medical issues. I read the reviews on this site and others before starting the program. My advice to anyone, is to do your research and make your choice.

I am extremely nervous about needles. I thought I would NEVER be able to administrer the HCG. However, I am tired of having the excess weight "more". So you make a decision on what you want and make a choice.

I don't have any regrets on my choice to get myself in shave via the HCG route. I'm not sure if anyone here is also inclding this with the 500cal diet, but if so. This is challenging but well worth it and I don't think that it's impossible.

To date, I have lost 8pds during my first week. So I'm into my 2nd week now. I'll report my loss after I get weighed in on this coming Friday Dr's visit.

As always, Good Luck and Good Health to all :) posted Nov 8th, 2009 5:10 pm


Frog

Thumbs Down

Have you even read the "Pound and Inches" by Dr. Simeons???? You couldn't have possible published such ignorant and closed-minded article if you have. Your statement about the 500 calories would be true if there weren't for the hcg. With the hcg on board this is perfectly safe, simply because you are targeting your own fat reserves. Fat is a great source of energy!!!! I have been on this diet for a while, lost great amount of fat (not just weight, FAT) and I feel great. No impact on my brain or muscles whatsoever. Please get ALL your facts before you go bashing something you don't know anything about. posted Nov 8th, 2009 8:16 am


kjlewis

Comment

I started the Hcg 4 days ago and have begun having migraines. I have also felt irritable and cranky. I have visitors coming in today (Nov.7) so I'm going to postpone the diet and start again next week. Does anyone have any suggestions on how to avoid the cranky/ headache symptoms? I hate to stop but I can't feel this bad while I'm entertaining company for the week. I may try again after they leave. I ended up having to take Imitrex yesterday for the headache. I haven't had a migraine in years so I'm pretty sure it's the Hcg hormone. posted Nov 7th, 2009 8:36 am


beth green

Comment

I am signed up for these injections. I have also once developed a blood clot after a complicated surgical procedure that required me to sit up to recuperate.
DOES ANYONE HAVE DIRECT KNOWLEDGE OF THE BLOOD CLOT SIDE EFFECT? posted Nov 7th, 2009 8:26 am


BJ

Thumbs Up

dont knock it until you try it. This is working for a lot of people. Ignorance to any knowledge of HCG is evedent. Apparenlty you and your body are perfect . Don't know what makes you any authority on anything. posted Nov 7th, 2009 5:24 am


Barbara

Thumbs Up

Okay, I am convinced. This stuff is worth a try. I am confused on whether to go to a clinic or buy from the internet. Is the HCG you buy on the net the same as in a clinic ? Does the sublingual work as well as the injectable? posted Nov 6th, 2009 11:02 pm


LeahStorm

Comment

I agree with cac4me. This review is not based on facts.
I also have a few points to make with Mera, the athletic champion that runs 30 miles a week, and thinks it's ok to criticize everyone else, as if they never tried to exercise.
Mera, you, like the article above, tried to scare people from using this drug, but failed to mentioned facts and statistics that could be backed up with studies, or even your own experience.
Of the people who HAVE had experience using hCG as a weight loss tool, none of them have had bad experiences.
HCGhopeful has nailed it, you over simplified a very complicated struggle.
hCG has been used for weight loss for over 50 years. It's not just the drug that helps, its the change in lifestyle afterward.

I'm on day 24 of my first round of hCG. I've lost 15 pounds. I have PCOS, and I'm fine.
My sister has lost 14 pounds, eating the vegetarian version of the diet.

I'm paying $125 for a 30 day supply of injectable hCG. I have a friend in a clinic, but I know his cost on it is $50. If you are paying more, I would hope your care includes blood work, weekly dr. visits, and your dr. being on call for any questions you have at any time.

Leah posted Nov 6th, 2009 10:10 am


cac4me

Comment

Thanks Megan. I appreciate the positive feedback. I'm due for my first weekly check up w/the Dr. tomorrow 11/6/09. This will include another B12 shot. Plus I will be provided with another 7day supply. So of course I'll be able to get my measurements documented as well. Stay Tuned and Good Luck to all :) posted Nov 5th, 2009 5:52 pm Profile send message  Message


cac4me

Comment

First and foremost. This review is not based on facts. The facts would be from this person's own experience. I just started the program on Friday Nov 30, 2009. I am going through the HCG program via diet clinic. Since starting the program. I have "not" had any terrible side effects. The 500cal diet is very strick and I will say is a "challenge". I'm finding that if I eat between meals I'm not as hungry at meal time. Also, I try to eat my meals the same time everyday. I do fine in the morning and lunch. When I get home, is when the challenge begins.

I've also been running on my treadmill everyday since starting the plan. I've been running up to 1mi per day. Additionally, I do situps and other exercises. I will say that on Tuesday, Nov 3, 2009. I CHEATED when I came home from work. Due to all the candy that I kept around my house from Holloween over the weekend. After eating the candy and being on this 500cal diet. I suffered from a really bad migraine headache. I decided not to take any meds for it and lied down instead. The next morning (today) Nov 4, 2009. I felt 100% better and no headache. Also, I have been trying to take in a minimum of 2QTS of water. I feel better when I'm taking in plenty of water. I will continue to post here with my results as I continue on the program. I checked on numerous sites for reviews to the HCG Program. From what I've read thus far. There appears to more positive feedback than negative. Including the one posted above. Here's to seeing less of me soon :) posted Nov 4th, 2009 5:32 pm Profile send message  Message


megan

Comment

hcghopeful...i hope it can work out for you. i kno how you have been feeling.. jus keep with the diet and u will begin to see changesi promise you. just remember how you felt before and it will help you not to cheat. this is what i have done!! good luck and god bless!! posted Nov 4th, 2009 3:55 am


HCGhopeful

Comment

Went to clinic and got first injection today along with B12 excited and optimistic.

Starting Weight: 252lbs
Height: 5"9

To Mera, of course you have to work out and "eat right," everyone knows that. Unfortunately is not as simple as saying just eat right and get your body moving. Some people do that and lose NOTHING. Exercising and eating right is not always enough for certain people. Especially those who yoyo diet. Some people need a jump start to their diet. That is where HCG comes into play. You may not understand. What you should understand is that losing weight is an extremely complicated process, it's not simple, so don't simplify other people's struggle. Because is truly is a struggle. posted Nov 3rd, 2009 9:56 pm


Mera

Thumbs Up

As a former fertility patient, I have lots of experience with injectable hCG. It is not a drug to be taken lightly and if I didn't have to take it to have a baby, I certainly wouldn't. After my daughter was born, I lost 50 lbs by working out and watching what I eat. Was it easy? No. I have PCOS and hypothyroid, so losing weight is never easy for me. However I don't believe that drugs and severely restrictive diets are the way to go. Instead, I started walking then running several times a week. I now run 25-30 miles a week, spin several times a week, and participate in weight training classes. I eat a sensible (ie healthy) diet. I was a couch potato and now am training for a full marathon (I've already run several half marathons). Eat right and move your body - it's not easy but it DOES work. posted Nov 3rd, 2009 4:47 pm


simplegirl

Comment

Can someone tell me how much this costs and if there is a place in Chicago I can get this?

Thanks posted Nov 3rd, 2009 12:29 am Profile send message  Message


HCGhopeful

Comment

Thanks for all of the positive feedback. Have an appointment with a HCG clinic tomorrow. I am desperate to lose weight, don't qualify for Lapband BMI 38, tried everything; Weight Watchers, The Zone, South Beach, Atkins, Medifast, Starving myself, Slim Quick, Phentermine, Xenadrine with and without Ephedra, Alli, Dexatrim, you name it I tried it. I am praying to God that HCG works, knees hurt, depressed, always tired, depressed. I NEED HELP. Pray for me please I need a miracle. posted Nov 2nd, 2009 8:03 pm


leela77

Thumbs Down

I lost 100 pounds on the HCG diet, in 3 rounds. Far more than I was ever able to lose on any other diet. Unfortunately after a year of keeping the weight off, I gained it back after eating poorly having to live in hotel rooms around the country for work. I have never needed my diabetes medication since I started the first round, no matter how I ate.
I did an accidental experiment on myself and discovered the HCG does indeed have a powerful effect. On my 4th round, returning to the diet, I was hungry all the time, had a very hard time staying with the diet, and wasn't losing weight. I finally remembered I had tried a new brand of HCG. I went back on my original brand, and immediately started losing weight very quickly, and had no trouble with the diet again. It also goes to show you that just being on a 500 cal a day diet in no way insures weight loss for those of us who's metabolisms are so messed up that we are very overweight. posted Nov 1st, 2009 7:56 pm


Megan

Comment

well i have been on the diet 17 days and have lost 12 lbs. i think my most motivation is that i spent 700 dollars on it so there for i dont want to waste my money. for people in this article who say these things. i think that its a lose lose situation both ways. if i wasnt on the diet i would still be eating processed fatty foods!! and that isnt healthy now is it? it has helped me see all the bad things that i have been eating. i have had NO side effects other than being hungry. and i dont think that you can lose this much with just a 500 day diet. IT WORKS!! you have to stick to the diet. i have cheated maybe two days on the diet and didnt lose anything for those days. but i have never seen this much weight loss in anything i have tried. and i think that if you go back to the way u were eating before from any diet you will gain back not jus from this diet!! so i say IT WORKS! its expensive but it works!! posted Nov 1st, 2009 5:54 pm


kok454

Comment

I am doing the diet as we speak, I felt a little faint the first weak... But I feel fine now, and I've lost 17 pounds in 3,5 weeks... The diet isn't as bad... All I have once in a while is that I have a craving for something later in the evening. posted Oct 29th, 2009 4:38 pm


antonieta

Comment

today it is my 3rd day, meaning i just started the 500 cal diet i have read many successful comments about this diet so i wanted to give it a try. i have done anphetamines and lost 15 pounds but got stuck and stopped losing weight that is why i m trying something new, that besides looks healthier since im not having the dangerous pills. i hope this diet works for me as wee as for you guys... posted Oct 29th, 2009 2:29 pm


ninthmuse

Comment

wow!! can't believe you even have the nerve to state all these apparent facts when it is your claims that are baseless. you have no idea what you are talking about and i question your motivation in writing something that berates a proven and workable method of losing fat (note - i didn't say weight). you should get off your soapbox and stay off it. what's wrong with you? posted Oct 29th, 2009 10:42 am


LINDA

Thumbs Down

Your article is biased...I have just finished the first 6 weeks of the HCG diet and I am doing WONDERFUL!!! I have had no sides effects, except to LOSE 25lbs of useless fat and have felt wonderful. As for the 500 calories, I can tell you that I found it satisfying and did not feel deprived. The fat stores released by the HCG add up to a 2000 to 3000 calories that the body uses..... I am an RN who researched this diet and am in no way convinced that this is bad for anyone willing to lose the weight in this manner.... posted Oct 27th, 2009 3:04 pm


JennSavage

Thumbs Down

I have lost 20 lbs on HCG without any side affects other than feeling 100% better about my body and fitting into clothes I haven't been able to wear for 5 years because of my weight gain. I believe anyone who is negative on this diet either knows nothing about it, has never tried it, or has some other product they would rather sell. Otherwise, it works...my brother in-law has lost 80 lbs since Mar. 2009, and I have known many others who are pleased with their results... posted Oct 26th, 2009 2:08 pm


kimberly

Thumbs Down

WOW, reading this article is like being back in the dark ages! If I was writing an article, I would actually do research of people who have done this diet CORRECTLY.
I am a member of many HCG dieter's groups and have seen so many success stories as well as what I have personally accomplished.

Many of the HCG clinics poping up on every street corner do not follow Dr. Simeon's protocol. They often don't offer much support for their patients.
Read Dr. Simeon's Pounds & Inches. Try it for yourself. THEN, write a report.
There is a science behind why this works. I spent weeks reading / researching this protocol before I tried it myself. I read Dr. Simeon's book 4 times!

I would love to read an update from you once you have done your homework as I stated above. I have no doubt, you would change your mind completely and write a glowing report of HCG for weightloss using Dr. Simeon's protocol.
(Also, many of use Homeopathic HCG as it doesn't have any side effects.) posted Oct 26th, 2009 1:18 pm


Victor Mace

Comment

The author of the above article has grand sympathies and maybe even a kick back from the FDA. Its a shame to have to say that but the article is so obviously in line with FDA money grabbing policies with big pharma its silly, and whats quite obvious is the author is only stating what shes been told to state. Ive done the diet and lost 72lbs and can safely say I have never felt better. The article is a poor attempy at journalism and is only tarnishing her own professionalism. posted Oct 25th, 2009 11:34 am


buttercup

Thumbs Down

The company I work for has recently started a weight loss incentive plan. I am in charge of the official weigh ins. Some of the participants are doing diet and excercise and struggling. I have personally witnessed weight loss with HCG both injections and drops, both seem equally effective. Female 63yr of age 24lbs in 30 days and has kept it off. Male 55yr of age 34 pounds in 30 days. Male 42yr of age 17lbs in 12 days. Each and every case they were not hungry, never felt better and were extremely happy with the results. I don't care what anyone says, I have witnessed successful weight loss with no side effects. posted Oct 25th, 2009 12:27 am Profile send message  Message


PLR

Comment

I would happen to disagree with the author of this article. I have 2 rounds of HCG and I have have lost 85lbs. My HCG had to be adjusted withthe second round but I wasn"t hungry and and my energy level remand high. Sure on a 500 KCAL diet alone you would hardly be able to function but I was able to do 40 mins of cardio, 30 min of weights and play tennis for 2hrs without any problem. I am a nurse and work 12-16hrs days and have no problems. I drink plenty of water and tea. It is a mind set and a life style change. It isn"t a quick fix system. It is a life long change and the HCG helps you to accomplish that goal. You need to have the mind set and a good support system to help you along the way. I recommend this diet to everyone who wants to lose weight, but I also inform them that it isn"t as easy as some make it out to seem. It takes dedication. You TRULEY have to put 110% into. The result are amazing!!!! Please dont let articles like this scare you. Research it. Talk to your doctor or find a doctor who offers this and talk with them. I have had no side effects from the injections but not everyone is the same. There are side effects with any medication you take, even tylenol or advil. Just educate yourself and see if works for you. It worked GREAT for me. posted Oct 24th, 2009 9:15 am


LeahStorm

Thumbs Down

UGH!! More scare tactics. If you can't make a buck, poo poo it, right? God forbid anyone learn to eat fruit, veggies and lean meats!!

I'm on hcg now. I'm 41/F. I'm on day 9, and have lost 6 pounds. That's 9 days including the first 3 when i ate anything and everything I wanted. I even went to an all you can eat buffet on day 3 and had a full plate of dessert. (oink)

I'll repost again in a few weeks to let you know how I feel. I'm keeping a journal. Yes, I'm hungry from time to time, but if you eat little bits steadily throughout the day, it's easier. Apples are quite filling.

My sister is a vegetarian. She started same day I did, and has lost 7 pounds. She eats egg whites instead of meat. She's 24.

We use the injectable hcg, and we do it at home. We weigh daily. We smile every time.

I'm happy to discuss with anyone about this. posted Oct 23rd, 2009 6:07 pm


tiffany

Thumbs Down

i think this is just a post from the fda trying to keep people fat. i use hcg diet drops, i baught the 15 day ones and i lost bout 15 lbs in 12 days. im not hungry, i stopped when i got to my goal and i didnt gain anything back (even when i pigged out on chinese food a week later) and i had no ill sideeffects. the fda doesnt support it because they would lose money in all the people being addicted to deadly toxic food, their diet shit and even laxatives. posted Oct 20th, 2009 10:45 pm


bigrockhouse

Comment

does anyone now if the HCG sublingual drops are as affective as the injected HCG? Where is the best place to order HCG? posted Oct 18th, 2009 11:39 pm


Lisa Manion

Thumbs Up

Can someone tell me if you repeat the 2 gorging days each time you do another round? It seems to me that you would need to, but it doesn't seem clear anywhere. posted Oct 18th, 2009 4:09 am


Jane

Comment

bottom line - it works! posted Oct 16th, 2009 3:11 am


diane

Comment

Does anyone know where to get this in Jacksonville, FL?? posted Oct 15th, 2009 9:49 pm


Lori

Thumbs Down

I am thinking of starting this program along with my naturpathic Dr. who I trust. However, the cost is around $800.00 for the 43 days. After reading the feedback and convinced that this is something I am going to do, the price seems a high. posted Oct 13th, 2009 3:32 pm


Joey

Comment

My fiance and I have been doing the hCG diet for one week, and it has been very challenging. I have watched my fiance work her tail off with diet and excercise and lost nothing, in fact has gained. In the first week of this diet we have both lost ~6lbs. We are both college educated and analyze things to death. Yes sure if you go back to your old ways after this diet you will most likely gain weight back. We are looking at this as an opportunity to restart or eating habbits and reset our life. I am very encouraged with the results that I have read about here, and witnessed with close friends that have had success with this diet. posted Oct 13th, 2009 1:22 am


ashley

Thumbs Down

I JUST ORDERED MY HCG AND CAN NOT WAIT FOR IT TO GET HERE. THERE IS ABOUT 6 OR 7 PEOPLE WHO DID THIS DIET WHO NOW LOOK AMAZING AND FEEL AMAZING. IF YOU HAVE NEVER TRIED IT I DONT THINK YOU HAVE ANY RIGHT TO SAY IT DOESNT WORK OR IS BAD posted Oct 12th, 2009 6:23 pm


Anonymous

Thumbs Up

I paid $1700 to sign up at a local "cattle call" hcg center in Dallas. It's impossible. 500 calories of nothing but tomatoes, oranges, grapefruit and chicken. By the end of the first week I was so hungry and tired, I binged and gained back the meager 2 lbs I had lost. I tried three more times (I still have another 20 day supply of hcg in my medicine cabinet), and the same thing happened. The weight would not come off and I starved myself to where I could hardly function. This is a huge scam. People that can stay on a 500 calorie a day diet don't need the shot -- the diet will work on it's own. But its carb-free and sugar free, so the minute you eat a single carb, you will gain all of the weight back. Buyer beware! posted Oct 12th, 2009 12:35 am


JP

Comment


Here are the results of actual scientifically controlled studies which were conducted in 1976, 1987, 1990, and 1995. Do we really have to perform the study again every time the hCG marketing engine revs up for another round of money making? In 1976, Researchers Stein, Julis, Peck , Hinshaw, Sawicki, and Deller concluded: "There was no statistically significant difference in the means of the two groups in number of injections received, weight loss, percent of weight loss, hip and waist circumference, weight loss per injections, or in hunger ratings. HCG does not appear to enhance the effectiveness of a rigidly imposed regimen for weight reduction." A review of 20 available studies published in the German Medical Journal "Geburtshilfe und Frauenheilkunde" concluded "These studies showed a significant weight reduction during dieting, but no differences between treatment groups in respect of body weight, body proportions and feeling of hunger," and "...the opinion of the German steroid toxicology panel is still valid, that hCG is ineffective in dieting and should not be used." A review of the data by Lijesen, Theeuwen, Assendelft, and Van Der Wal published in the British Journal of Clinical Pharmacology said plainly "We conclude that there is no scientific evidence that HCG is effective in the treatment of obesity; it does not bring about weight-loss of fat-redistribution, nor does it reduce hunger or induce a feeling of well-being." There are more, but I'll save you the time, the conclusions are the same.

HCG Diet Conflict of Interest?

So, the studies agree with hCG people on one point. On a strict very low calorie diet supervised by a doctor, you will lose weight quickly. However, the hCG proponents would have you believe that you need to buy daily doses of the hCG pregnancy hormone (from them) and inject it daily in order for the diet to work. Hmm? See any conflict of interest there?

Additional sources: Study results retrieved from August 25th, 2008.

from: Associated Press Article. posted Oct 11th, 2009 7:47 pm



Rebecca Scritchfield

Comment

I always appreciate feedback from people, without the personal attacks some have left here.

I'm very happy to get in a discussion with someone if they can send peer-review journal published research studies on how HCG effectively resets metabolism and promotes long term weight loss success.

Has anyone kept weight off for longer than 2 years?

Also, I posted this content on my personal blog and got a few supporters as well as several people who came out and said that it did not work for them.

http://rebeccascritchfield.wordpress.com/2009/09/16/thinking-about-hcg-diet-look-elsewhere-for-weight-loss/#comment-6842 posted Oct 10th, 2009 2:35 pm Profile send message  Message


CJ

Thumbs Down

This article is uninformed. Yes, this diet would be dangerous @5oo calories a day IF hcg didn't do what it's supposed to do - move excess stored nutrients into the bloodstream. The reason the metabolism doesn't suffer is because it is constantly being "fed" from one's own fat stores. (That's why metabolism changes for the better during and after the diet).

HcG does work as the protocol says it will, and I've lost 60 pounds. I've maintained the loss for one year, and my:

BMI is now normal
Blood pressure is in the low-normal range
Cholesterol levels are very good now
Metabolism is up from original test

Kevin Trodeau has many reputation issues, but just because he wrote a book on it doesn't mean the diet is a fraud too. posted Oct 6th, 2009 2:13 pm


Jeff A Watters

Thumbs Down

It is amazing to me that people can write such bogus information based on their logic rather than truth. Truth is I have been injecting for 32 days now and have over 20 punds off and have neither been hungry, light headed, cranky but on the contrary...full of energy and life...people who write articles of discouragement are just that discouraging! posted Oct 6th, 2009 10:13 am


Steph

Comment

I have been on hcg for 19 days and have lost 13 pounds so far. I did tons of research and reading before starting this program. The most interesting thing that I discovered is this:

There are thousands of accounts of success stories. There are also lots of articles warning against hcg for weight loss. What I couldn't find? Any actual account of someone who has used hcg unsuccessfully.

That spoke to me more than anything. All of the naysayers out there seem to be people who haven't actually tried it. Everyone who has actually tried it seems to love it.

And you can now add me to that number. I have about 60 more pounds to lose to get to a healthy BMI for my height. My doctor says it will probably take the rest of this round (~23 more days) and one more round of 25 days to get there.

Finally, even if there were some minor side effects (I haven't experienced any to date), they couldn't possibly be worse for my body than what carrying around 75 extra pounds was for me.

Thanks for all of the support and positive messages here! posted Oct 5th, 2009 7:22 pm


Dee

Comment

I am wondering where other participants of the HCG diet are buying the product and / or if they are going through a diet center for the product and monitoring process? Also what is the most accurate way to measure the body fat so I can compare the before and after? posted Oct 5th, 2009 1:26 am


Amy

Thumbs Down

I don't believe a word this author is saying. I'm on the HCG diet and I feel wonderful. I was in a rut with no energy for a long time, taking naps and laying on the couch all day; and being on this diet pulled me right out of it. I'm eating like a normal person, not like a morbidly obese person! I used to eat every time I felt a twinge of hunger, or even when I wasn't hungry at all! But I am retraining my mind that I don't need to eat every hour; I will be fine if I'm a little hungry. HCG IS A LIFESTYLE CHANGE. It teaches you to eat right - that's what I love about it. I wish the FDA would approve this hormone for weight loss! posted Oct 4th, 2009 10:50 pm


Shelia

Comment

I've been thinking about doing this diet at a place called "40 pounds in 40 days," but I'm curious about the cost. It sounds really expensive to me. Could someone tell me approximately the cost of the program? posted Oct 4th, 2009 2:44 pm


Tbone

Thumbs Up

The diet is a joke. It's a fad that will come and go just like everything else. The only drug that has been shown to mobilize and burn fat is clebuterol/albuterol. HCG doesn't do squat. I tried this diet, felt like death, and quit. Maybe if I were morbidly obese I would lay on the couch all day and tough it out. But for 15lbs, no way in hell would I deal with this stupid diet again. posted Oct 3rd, 2009 9:40 pm


christine

Comment

I just started the hcg diet 7 days ago and have lost just over five pounds. It is one of the hardest things I have ever tried, but it works! My goal is to lose 20 lbs. and I intend to stick it out. I would never do this diet if my metabolism did not end up being significantly faster in the end. That is what makes it worth it. The doctor whose care I'm under also wants me to do 3 weeks of 1000 calorie days after the hcg is over before returning to my normal way of eating. Of course if you eat 3 big macs and tons of sugar everyday I could see how you would gain the weight back, but I have always been a sensible eater. My metabolism just needs a good kick in the pants and that is whatt this does. posted Oct 1st, 2009 7:30 pm


TIA

Thumbs Down

Ok, I am on this diet and yes, you do get some side affects.. but lets think about it for a second... The headaches are common for up to a week and it is because (NOT THE HCG ITSELF) it is because you are taking MSG, SODA, FAT, SUGAR, CARBS, ALL sorts of stuff is being taken away from your body that you are use to eating every day and so you get headaches because you dont have the sugar or the caffeine to thin the blood. It is kind of like a caffeine headache and even those go away. but your body goes through a little period of shock if you will. Lets turn it around... if you are a VERY healthy eater and dont drink soda or eat fast food... then you do a "diet" and eat a ton of junk and soda, carbs, sugar, etc... (like super size me) then you will have the same affects. Headache, dizzy, sick, grumpy, tired... but that is because you are doing something different that your body is not use to. We as a country eat out a lot... mostly because we dont have time to cook, or dont want to cook, or whatever the excuse is... we eat out a lot and so were use to chemicals and bad things go into the body that when you actually take that away from the body, you WILL have side affects. BUT those side affects are for the better of the body. You have to re train the body and tell it what is actually GOOD for the body. I have been on the HCG diet now for 20 days and have lost 25 lbs. I "cheated" on the diet once and I seriously hated every second of it! I could taste the gross chemicals of the fries, and I was SOOOOO sick after! I couldn't even eat the rest of the food either! I guess i trained my body well! :) posted Sep 30th, 2009 8:08 pm


ruthie

Comment

THANK YOU ERIKA FOR YOUR COMMENT ON 9-23-09. I ALSO HAVE BEEN USING HCG WITHOUT THERE DIET. I COULD NEVER CUT MYSELF TO 500 CALORIES. I HAVE LOST 9 POUNDS BUT MOST IMPORTANT I HAVE LOST INCHES. posted Sep 29th, 2009 10:57 am


Christian

Thumbs Down

This author has obviously never tried the hCG diet and is rehashing information from sources that not only haven't tried it but they most likely have never read any of Dr. Simeon's research. (I wish people would do research before touching the keyboard.)

I lost 42 pounds on this diet in about 40 days with little to no side effects. Having said that I realize that individuals react differently to each diet and this diet may not be for everyone. If you do not mix the hCG correctly you will have poor side effects, but if you mix it correctly and you load correctly you will not lose lean muscle tissue, but you will burn pure body fat.

CW posted Sep 28th, 2009 11:08 am


Amanda

Comment

I have been considering starting this diet and am researching it right now. The one person I know that is doing this diet has lost 120 pounds since March! She is all the evidence I need. posted Sep 24th, 2009 4:21 pm


UNI

Comment

WHERE CAN I BUY IT? posted Sep 23rd, 2009 8:35 pm


Deb

Thumbs Up

Coworkers have tried it and have had side effects with HCG.

Tiredness
Mind numbness (fog brain), can't think
Hunger
Weakness, can't exercise


for more HCG side effects. If there is some in any "drug" then there is some cause to think. Not only in those wanting to lose weight but in other people who may take this "drug" as well.
posted Sep 22nd, 2009 6:46 pm


christine

Thumbs Up

The best thing I have ever done! No side effects, evenly distributed weight loss, better sleep patterns. Calm, happy, etc. It has been a year since I lost my weight and have kept it off entirely. posted Sep 22nd, 2009 5:15 pm


CR Smith

Thumbs Up

Lost 20 lbs in 20 days and very happy about this diet. Is it buring muscle, or fat? I go to the gym every day and took a body fat test on this diet. HIGHLY RECOMENDED.

I Started with 33% body fat x 250lbs, or 82 lbs of fat.

After 20 days I am at 228lbs and 27.7% body fat or 63 lbs of fat.

If you subtract the two you get 19lbs, of fat. I have lost 21 lbs, so clearly most of my loss is fat.

The diet works, but it needs to be a kickoff on a behavior change on eating. We should be eating less, not so late, not so often and avoiding sugar.

Guys - Obesity is one of the #1 killers and it's growing at a fast rate. Sleep apena, joint pain and so much more are the result of a round belly. It also cuts many years from our life if we are heavy. This diet (if it works) and the side effects associated with it are irrelivant compared to the positive effects of reducing obesity risk.

I wish you all well on your diet and future. I for one am planning to change my behavior after this is over. To a healty future !!!! posted Sep 21st, 2009 12:18 pm


Erica

Comment

I completed the 23 day cycle of HCG about a month ago. According to the doctor, if you eat ANYTHING other than the 500 calorie diet you will gain weight. This was not true for me. I ate whatever I wanted, I just ate small portions, healthier food and worked out. I lost 15 pounds and I'm still keeping it off. posted Sep 20th, 2009 12:42 pm


Lisa

Comment

I just wanted to leave a note for all those who are or have just been completed the HCG diet. I did the diet last year after years of struggling to rid myself of unwanted baby weight. I'm not going to rosy it up by saying it was in any way easy. It was one of the hardest things I have ever done, but it worked so fast, it kept me going. It has been one year today since I completed the 40 day program (I did it with a doctor in a clinic where I was monitored weekly) and I still have not gained the weight back. Granted, I have kept up a good exercise plan and try to eat right. There have been a few side effects though that I believe are probably due to the hormone surge. I did lose hair after I completed the program. It is now growing back in. I have also noticed that my PMS symptoms are more severe than before and my skin tends to break out a lot more than it did. Other factors could be contributing to this, but I know that all those things can be hormone related. But, in retrospect, I would do it all over again. I lost 40lbs in 40 days (back down to my pre-baby weight) and it took me 8 months to lose 20 before that with hard exercising and dieting.
Take that for what you will because I have seen a lot of people fail on the diet, but if you mean it and you follow it, it works. posted Sep 19th, 2009 1:49 am


Paula

Thumbs Down

HCG is just a natural hormone that helps stimulate your metabolism. People can maintain that low calorie diet because you are absorbing about 1500 calories in body fat a day. So you do not feel hungry. The HCG diet would not be effective if you kept eating regularly.
posted Sep 17th, 2009 7:54 pm


Jenny

Comment

@Kelly
So true I was in the drug business for a while. If you claim that your drug is 'guaranteed' to cure/help with something. The FDA will come after you.
-
I just started thhe HCG diet myself because i have seen many have good results. I was a non believer at first. The original HCG diet can be dangerous. The original HCG diet protocol started out everyone with the same amount of calories (500) and protein (200) grams. It didn't matter if a person was 6'10" and 450 pounds or 4'2" and 190 pounds with heart disease. Just plain common sense tells you this is wrong and we all know that a one size fits all diet does not exist! Dr. Simeons patients had to go back to a normal diet after they treatment. This resulted in regaining a lot of the weight they lost. The modern HCG diet may provide Faster Safer Easier Weight Loss than the original. Here you can find more info about the program that i am on:
posted Sep 17th, 2009 7:50 pm


Cathy

Comment

As with any diet program, if you don't change your eating habits and exercise, the weight will return. I agree, HCG is not a magic pill that will make the weight disappear and stay gone even if you return to your "normal" pre-HCG life patterns.

I know now, when I manage to get in even just 30 minutes of walking every couple of days and try to keep the carbs and sweets to a minimum, my weight will remain stable. But if I pig out (which I have done) for more than two or three days and slack off walking, I pack the weight on very quickly. I have to eat very clean ( veggies, fruit, and lean meat only) for a week to get off two or three days of transgressions. The trick is to recognize this quickly and not let it get away from you.

The HCG is just another diet program and, like any diet program, it will work if you follow the rules. The difference is..it will work quickly which provided great motivation for me to adhere to the strict eating plan. Plus, eating as the plan dictates, especially for that length of time, did help me change my behaviors because I realized it really isn't that hard to plan ahead and make good choices.

As far as the foggy brain goes, after about three days on the HCG protocol I really felt the fog lift - I felt like I was thinking more clear then that I had in years. I'm sure it has something to do with cutting the sugar and carbs out of my diet, but it taught me an important lesson about what I was putting in my body before and how it was really affecting me. I have no doubt if I go back to my pre-HCG eating patterns, I will gain the weight back. It doesn't a dietician to figure that out, it is just common sense. HCG will work but not without making permanent life changes once the injections are over. posted Sep 16th, 2009 5:42 pm


beatrice

Comment

I read all of these comments and can't help but wonder......are these the same types of comments made by those people who were thrilled with the miracle drug fen/phen? Just wondering..... posted Sep 16th, 2009 4:12 pm


BKiddo

Comment

WOW!! lot of "BELEIVERS" in this talkback :). I am a registered dietician and have helping people get into shape for the last 12 years. Using HCG for weight loss has been around since 1954 or so but in the last couple of years I have seen a staggering increase in it's use. In just the last 2 months i have had 7 differnet clients come to see me who have done the hcg injections combined with the diet. Some on their own and others under a physician's care. ALL of them had gained their weight back and 5 of the 7 had gained it back in less than 4 months and then some. One woman had lost over 60 lbs. and had gained it back in 3 MONTHS!! Another female hadn't gone off the diet yet because her daughter and friends had gained their weight back and she was hoping i could help her keep it off. People, even if this was the "miracle" drug everyone has been waiting for there is NO SUBSTITUTE for exercise and a "healthy" diet. Don't let yourself beleive that this hormone is "JUST NOW" being used and working when it has been around for YEARS!! Anyone will lose weight on 500 calories a day. Come talk to me once your bring your caloric intake back up to where your brain functions normally, we'll see how well that weight has stayed off. posted Sep 14th, 2009 3:22 pm


Cathy

Thumbs Up

Logically a person would read about the HCG diet and think the claims were crazy, but after actually completing one 43 day round of the program I lost 30 pounds and felt better than I ever had.

I took a multi-vitamin, B-12 drops, and ate exactly as the plan recommended. I was able to give up beer (which I enjoyed every weekend), sweets (which I indulged in everyday), and caffeine (which I was completed addicted to) without difficulty. I had a slight headache the first two days but beyond that I had no other negative side effects - actually I had quite the opposite. I was having some stomach issues before going on the HCG protocol such as gas, acid reflux, and cramps. All of those issues completely disappeared which I attribute to eating only fruits, veggies, and lean protein (no fatty or fried foods) and not exactly to the HCG but the HCG did give me the will power to make better choices. I tried veggies I had never tried before, learned to love fruit, and enjoyed the taste of my food without alot of sauces and other added ingredients.

I had alot of energy, slept well, and lost weight in areas that were very difficult before such as around my waist and upper back. I have stayed off of the HCG for the last eight weeks and kept my weight stable within three pounds. I will be starting round two this weekend and I can't wait to drop another 25 to 30 pounds. I am going to a local doctor and having my prescription filled at an actual pharmacy though, buying anything injectable over the Internet is crazy to me, but not the HCG program itself. posted Sep 14th, 2009 2:54 pm


smity

Comment

You critics need to keep your opinons to yourself unless you tries the HCG diet. I have researched this more than anyone. I even read the origional documents written in the 1950's. I have lost 35 pounds on this diet and I still have 14 days to go. I have tried every diet out there and this has been the only one that was true to its work. I have never experienced hunger or food cravings. And I never felt better. So before you make your comments- why do'nt you try the program and then form an opinion. posted Sep 12th, 2009 8:17 pm


richelle

Comment

im on my 4th injection and i am still hungry with headaches. Im 5ft 7 inches and weigh 155.8 so i need to loose 15 pounds. Is it a slower process for people who dont have a lot to loose? So far ive lost no weight. posted Sep 11th, 2009 5:22 pm


Erin

Thumbs Down

Like all of the rest of the comments, I agree completely with everyone on here. I've tried Jenny Craig, NutriSystem, the Cookie diet all with failure because I was so hungry and only lost 1 pound a week. With the hcg shots, I lost 7 pounds my first week and my cravings for bad food started to go away. Like any diet it is hard to do, but I can already tell that I have toned up and I'm not losing energy like other diets. I will admit that I do get headaches, but mainly because (my belief) I have not been drinking soda like I used to and eating as much sugar. I agree.....I believe the government is trying to control this because they know it works and we won't go dumping money into their hands on useless medications and weight loss remedies. posted Sep 10th, 2009 1:54 am


Lexie

Thumbs Up

I'm on my 2nd round of HCG and I love it! The 1st time I did the 43 day protocol and lost 28 lbs. and 7 additional during the 3 weeks of setting my metabolism at my new weight (with the help of some B12 shots with fat burner). I never felt better than when I was on the shots. I had more energy and I was so proud of myself for not drinking alcohol (which I love to consume every weekend) & being able to stick with such a strict diet. I found that food tastes great and doesn't need to be slathered with butter and sauces! The trick is to get inventive with your cooking (I love to cook so it was easy). In (4) months I kept 30 of my 35 lbs. off. I am now on the 26 day protocol, day 3 of the 500 calorie diet (after the 2 wonderful days of loading) & I have lost 5.2 lbs. so far. I'm someone who was looking at losing 100 lbs. +. What a difference 35 lbs. made and what I lose this time will make my weight loss goal 1/2 of what it was. All that weight loss in less than 4 months(when you add the round together)! That is very encouraging and very helpful! Lastly, the diet taught me to eat right and to eat better and to be aware of everything that I put in my mouth! I'm shocked by how sugar is in almost everything! Anyhow, I'm a firm believer in HCG and I am so glad I did it. I will say that I always do doctor supervised and I got my initial blood work done to make sure I could safely do the diet. I highly recommend you seeing a doctor for at least your 1st round. Good luck to all that decide to take this wonderous journey! posted Sep 9th, 2009 11:59 pm


Fred

Thumbs Down

Like almost everyone else I too am using the hcg diet. Lost 25 lbs in 40 days with no adverse side effects. Motivated because of the 5 1/2 inches from waist, with 0 inches lost on biceps or thighs; seems to be all from my fat tummy. Not hungry on 500 cal! Craved some before bedtime, but not bad. Cheated a little on the diet, but not much. Going for another 25 lbs after 3 weeks. Did under Dr. supervision with weekly checkups. Was able to stop both pills being taken for high blood pressure. My wife is a RN and the MD she works with is doing it. My sister is doing it, she is a PA and her daughter an MD. posted Sep 8th, 2009 3:13 am


Jonathan Colson

Thumbs Down

The hCG Protocol is a doctor prescribed weight loss program, designed by a doctor. Given that information, we know that there has to be a lot of MD's and ND's that are prescribing hCG for weight loss, because there is a enormous amount of individuals who are following the hCG diet.

As of this date, there have been no reported deaths due to the hCG Diet Protocol, period; whether the person was following the diet or not.

Yet, there seems to be a lot of 'guru's' out there that know everything about the diet, yet they have never spoken with a person who has actually followed the diet protocol.

Here is what they are missing when it comes to the calories. In order to lose weight, a person must reduce calories, right? That is because we are trying to force the body into burning those calories from fat, right? YES. If the dieter is succesful, then the weight is lost, right?

Then the question is, how many calories did that person have?

The amount of calories that person had was the amount of calories that were ingested PLUS the amount of calories burned from fat-stores. That means the person may have been enjoying the same amount of calories, yet they were eating less.

It is the same with hCG. If a person loses 1 lb a day consistently for 2 weeks, that is an extra 3500 calories that the body is getting from fat. Add the 500 calories, and the person is getting 4000 calories. That is why the hunger mechanism is turned off. The hypoithalamus regulates fat storage, body temprature, HUNGER, and functions to support the Pituitary and the Thyroid.

The hCG Diet is NOT a starvation diet. If it was, Dieters would be complaining of hunger, irritability, headaches, weakness, and much more.

After starting over 800 patients on the hCG program, this has not been a problem, and it is amazing to me still. posted Sep 4th, 2009 10:32 pm


Jonathan

Thumbs Down

Its funny that you can find so many articles about how hCG is bad, and every response you get from those who actually did the diet tell you different.

Of course hCG balances the endocrine system; look at how bodybuilders have used it for such a long time.

If you have something to pick with people who have an enormous amount of weight to lose, stop telling them its easy. I was a personal trainer, I have worked in the fitness industry my whole life, I now work as a Doctors Assistant, and I know that it isnt as easy as just eating less. When a person has over 100 lbs to lose, there are almost ALWAYS other problems that dont go away right away. Also,if they start working out at that heavy weight, they will often gain weight due to the stress they are placing on their body.

Others haver already pointed out how if you dont eat enough, your body will lose weight, adn compared it to Africa. Give me a break; after burning off all of your lean body mass.

Thats the problem. What do you think would happen if all of a sudden you started feeding all of those starving people in africa 3 large meals a day. Yep, thats right, they would blow up. posted Sep 4th, 2009 10:14 pm


valerie

Comment

O.k., I tried it and was almost a statistic. I read the book by Dr. Simeone. Here's the real deal. Don't attempt this diet without medical supervision. I became dizzy, numb, and had to have emergency treatment because I had blood clots. Which causes strokes and deaths. This is a serious drug and it can immobilize a person. Unless you have a medical background ...a true medical background. Don't attempt this diet. posted Sep 3rd, 2009 7:42 pm


brooke brayer

Thumbs Up

I am 24 years old and have a real problem trying to work out and eat healthy. I've done a couple "crash" diets and they never show any real results. I try to exercise, but as much as I work, its almost impossible to find time. I've been on the HCG diet for 4 days and lost 5 lbs. Lets keep in mind, what I'm trying to lose is vanity pounds, I'm actually at a rather healthy weight currently. (so those of you who think it ony works with those SERIOUSLY over weight, your wrong) I've slept like a baby for 4 days. I feel better and I already feel my jeans getting loose in 4 days. Its amazing. Its easy to stick to the diet when every morning you look forward to the weight loss. dont forget to take your sublingual B12!!!!! The happy vitamin. I've had no headaches, no issues. The comments below are correct. The FDA can suck it. They hate this diet because we buy it online instead of pouring money somewhere else. posted Aug 31st, 2009 11:58 am


nicole

Comment

OMG...as a person who has done fertility treatments I can guarntee there are side effects of injected or swallowing synthetic hormones. Some mild, some major. Though the FDA isn;t the best source for information, since they also have problems with people taking vitamin c..which I think we can all agree is harmless, there are many other sites which the author gets info from. Anyone can loss weight from eating 500 calories a day, this is not brain surgery people, however the idea that HCG resets your metabolism is ludacris. If that was the case many women would have no problem shedding pounds after pregnancy. If you want to be thin...STOP EATING. People in Africa are skinny because they DON'T EAT. Stop fooling yourselves, the brain is a powerful tool, and can convince you of anything if you believe it! posted Aug 30th, 2009 10:34 pm


Mona

Thumbs Down

Frankly, Rebecca, you obviously don't know what you're talking about regarding the hcg diet as proven by the number of responses you've gotten with not one person expressing a bad experience. As unconventional as the diet may sound, it is in fact working superbly for me. (I'm talking from experience...something you apparently are not doing.) This is my 16th day of the 26 day program and I've lost 8 lbs (I only need to lose 15 lbs.) without feeling hungry, nervous, irritable or without energy. I've even done my 20 mile bike ride every other day and have plenty of energy left! I've been on semi-starvation diets in the past which I could tolerate for maybe 8-10 days before I would feel the need to consume normal amts. of calories to function, with the weight returning shortly thereafter. Hcg is an amazing homeopathic way to assist one to loose those difficult pounds. By the way, it is certainly no diet for sissies as it takes determination and discipline to follow the program. I suggest you read Dr. Simeon's "Pounds and Inches" protocol and give it a try yourself before you start dissing an amazingly comfortable way available for people to deal with their unwanted poundage. My husband who is an old Covert Bailey fan can't believe the results I'm getting (as well as my upbeat mood...unlike other diets) and how easy it has been for me to adhere to the VLCD, and is considering it for himself. I still need to experience whether or not my metabolism resets to where I can eat sensible amounts of food without regaining the weight back, but so far everything that is written in Dr. Simeon's book has proven true as it relates to my situation. I'm looking forward to the final results at which time I will spread the word to those who can benefit.
The FDA can go jump in the lake on this one and frankly so can you! posted Aug 30th, 2009 8:52 pm


Krupst

Comment

I just started the HCG diet and can totally understand why people would say bad things about it by just hearing about what is required. I have been on it for 4 days and have lost about 4 lbs. I have not heard anyone that has tried the diet and done what is expected of them say that it didn't work. posted Aug 28th, 2009 6:55 pm


Antoinette

Comment

These comments are great. I am a insulin dependent diabetic and I can tell you it's hard to lose weight. The insulin stores itself in body fat and makes it very difficult to lose the weight. However, with this protocol I used less insulin because the insulin which is stored in my body fat releases itself resulting in a decreased need for insulin. One of the benefits is saving money on insulin and supplies. This is another reason the FDA probably hates this protocol. Do you realize how expensive insulin and supplies are?!! This protocol does work and the only side effect I have is a headache. Just imagine how many diabetics this protocol can help. My doctor recommended it to me because I was having difficulty losing weight. I would exercise 4 times a week for at least an hour and my diet was great but the insulin does make it difficult to lose weight. HCG works. posted Aug 25th, 2009 2:07 pm


sediqua

Thumbs Up

HCG for weightloss, was a godsend for me! I gained 40 pounds as a result of pregnancy, fertility drugs, and breast feeding, and my body, despite eating healthy, exercising, etc, would not shed the weight. I lost all the weight with HCG, and it was the easiest thing I've ever done. Not only that, but the fat melts off your problem areas. After you get off the protocol, you'll find that your body has reset and eventually, you can go back to eating normally after the protocol is done. I experienced no side effects, except euphoria the first week.

Like ANY detox protocol, here is where the problems comes in, but if you do what you are supposed to do they are not problems at all.

1) After being on a such a low calorie diet, you do not have an appetite anymore. You will find that you lose your taste for sweets, junk food, and typically all the bad stuff. People with no appetite are in danger of being mal nourished.

Thats what happened to me. I got so used to only eating lettuce, cabbage, and protein, etc.. that my body actually forgot how to metabolize carbs. I ended losing a lot of muscle mass, and despite the fact that I was skinny, and the same inche measurements as before, my body was still pretty flabby.

so what is important is to do and follow the protocol, and to slowly add carbs back, as your body may have developed new sensitivies.

The other bad thing, by being in starvation mode, your body is now open to more diseases. When you do gain weight on this protocal, the weight goes toward "structural" fat, which is the fat the surrounds your organs. Fat in problem areas may not LOOK attractive, but its definitely a healthier place for fat to be stored. So what a lot of people do, when they do gain weight, they go back on the protocal. This is a mistake. Each time you do the protocal you get weaker and weaker and kill your body. It is not long term solution, but a solution in which it is designed for you to get on, and then get off.

the problem is, just like any other type of habit, when you start down a path, you do not notice the bad side effects. Like I developed a habit of starving myself.

to help me get my body back on track, I've slowly developed a fat loss routine, to get rid of my new visceral fat, and building the muscle that I lost.

But I am still ahead of the game, than had I not done the HCG protocal at all. I look great, at least in my clothes, and now I am working on getting buff again. posted Aug 25th, 2009 1:09 pm


Kelly

Comment

the FDA does not approve anything they cannot get their hand in(pockets) They obviously won't approve anything out of our country because they can't make sure our government can get their take. It's all about money and getting paid off. Our government is as corrupt as the others but at least we get to call them on it. I'll take thousands of people like me at their word before I will listen to anything the FDA(Federal Dumb Asses)have to say. I get all of my weight loss drugs in other countries so they can kiss my American ass. posted Aug 24th, 2009 9:50 am


SRR

Thumbs Down

I will have to say that the HCG diet truly is real with great results! You should try it for yourself or have someone you know try it before taliking so negatively about it. I was on the diet and lost 40 lbs! I never felt hungry, only full of energy and self-confidence! posted Aug 22nd, 2009 4:19 pm


Karen

Comment

Do the HCG drops you put under your tongue work as well as the shots? posted Aug 20th, 2009 5:27 pm


Shannon Bachtell

Comment

Where are you all getting you HGC from? posted Aug 18th, 2009 5:04 pm


Brian

Thumbs Up

We provide HCG Meals and have seen hundreds of successful stories. In 3 days one customer lost 12 lbs. What other diet in the world, can you lose weight and not kill yourself with exercise? posted Aug 18th, 2009 2:17 am


Leslie Cox

Comment

This diet works. I am currently starting my second round after having lost 30 on my first round. My sister has lost 66 pounds in a total of three rounds. The hcg diet is cheap, effective, and easy to do. I ordered mine from an online Indian pharmacy and it arrived quickly and at cost of $13.00 per vial. There are no hunger pains or feelings of deprivation, the opposite is true. In this case, the phrase sounds too good to be true is wrong. posted Aug 15th, 2009 2:59 pm


Want2Btin

Thumbs Down

I was scared to go ahead and try the HCG diet when I read your article. But now that I am reading the reviews, I see not one person complaining. This gives me great confidence and have to say I cannot wait to start it. I need to lose 40 pounds max and hoping HCG will take care of it. posted Aug 15th, 2009 7:25 am


Sharkey

Comment

I started to believe this article until it mentioned the FDA. Don't trust that corrupt industry. That makes me laugh proving your point with the FDA posted Aug 13th, 2009 9:54 pm


Rhea

Comment

Both my mom and I have done HCG and had amazing results with it. I lost over 22 pounds in several weeks, and I have never had these results with diet or exercise (or anything else short of surgery for that matter- trust me I've tried it all).

I have tried to restrict my calories to 500 in the past without HCG (onviously not advised but I'm in the entertainment industry and have to lose weight quickly sometimes). Just by restricting my calorie intake to 500, there is no way I would lose a pound a day, or even close. Even on HCG, you can take the injections and eat only 200 calories of the wrong food (sugar, starches, fats)and not lose weight. You have to adhere **very** stricly to the diet or it won't work. That's why the studies that say it's ineffective, they are FLAWED. HCG acts as a safety net for pregnant women, so if their caloric intake gets too low, 2,500 calories a day are released into the body from excess fat stores. That's how you lose weight. It's not just 500 calories, because how could all these people do that successfully and still be happy and have any energy?

HCG injections *alone* will not make you lose weight, that's why pregnant women don't lose weight during pregnancy.

HCG Injections and a 500 calorie diet *alone* will make you lose a little weight temporarily due to the caloric intake reduction.

HCG Injections *and* Dr. Simeons rigid and specific diet will cause your body to release 2,500 calories a day from excess fat stores (not structural fat).

People that say HCG doesn't work **clearly** haven't tried it. No, it's not a magic injection, because the diet is still hard work, and it's easy to mess up just going out and eating the wrong thing.

I work at a place that does it in Tampa, Raydiance Wellness, and the number is (813)258-0458. There is a weekly weigh in and you are fully supported through every step. It's MD supervised, and they have lots of other things to help support you in making life changes and fixing what made you fat in the first place.

This is a link to a *properly* conducted double blind study on HCG.

posted Aug 12th, 2009 6:01 pm


MD's

Comment

My wife and I are both physicians and have been using this proven safe diet protocol for many years on thousands of patients successful. You should really spend more time doing some research. posted Aug 6th, 2009 5:02 pm


Margaret

Comment

Somebody has inserted an ad in the middle of my comment. It wasn't me and I didn't authorize the hijacking of my comment. posted Jul 31st, 2009 8:18 pm


Priscilla

Thumbs Down

I have finished my first 40 day round losing 24.4 pounds and 18 1/2 inches. I felt great, have a real sense of well being, more energy and feel better about myself. I just finished my maintenance phase and maintained my weight while eating what ever I wanted other than sugar and starch. I am now adding in sugar and starch, maintaining and feel great! I do not have the cravings that I did before. I am looking forward to starting back on the hcg and seeing the weight and inches disappear. I have been on many different diets with little success and always went back to the old ways. I really feel that I have found the Weight Loss Cure.
Maybe you should try it yourself or talk to people who have. I think you would change your mind. posted Jul 31st, 2009 7:18 pm


Grand Pubah

Thumbs Down

Rebecca, while I appreciate your attempt to talk about hcg and warn people of potentially negative diets, I have to say I do question where you got some of your information. The reason hcg was banned in baseball was not because it was harmful but because people were using it to cover up the use of illegal steroid use. Secondly you do not state the source of your information about adverse side effects of the hcg diet. Your conclusions of comparing it to a strict 500 calorie diet alone are incorrect. I would not recommend anyone to attempt a 500 calorie diet without hcg because your hypothesis would then be correct. However with the hcg because it mobolizes and releases the fat cells this is what your body burns (instead of muscle). As far as there being no medical research that confirms that there is no substantial evidence that it increases weight loss beyond that resulting from caloric restriction, that it causes a more attractive or ‘normal’ distribution of fat, or that it decreases the hunger and discomfort associated with calorie-restricted diets", you are incorect. There was a fairly recent double blind study by 3 doctors who proved much of the opposite of the statements in your article. The primary doctor was Dr. Daniel Belluscio. You may visit his website to corroberate my statements at http://www.oralhcg.com/English/index.htm. I personally lost have done many diets over the years without lasting success but had incredible results on the hcg diet losing 35 lbs in 35 days without any of the hunger, weakness, and struggles. I had on other diets. Idid have headaches 1 day early on in the diet as is typical due to body detoxifying. Please revist this issue and do a little more research before you jump to conclusions that may not apply to this diet all. As far as the side effects you listed of the hcg, I have never seen any of the studies done on it, or known anyone who has used it (for weight loss) who has had any of these. You did not refer to your source. On the hcg diet you take very small doses of the hcg not anything near like that used in fertilization techniques or by athletes. posted Jul 31st, 2009 12:01 pm


NESED

Thumbs Down

You really need to get your facts straight and/or should have spoken directly to a few HCG dieters. What you have written in your article actually gave me a giggle. As a HCG dieter, I have to say that I am not having any of the side effects you listed. ( headaches, mood swings, depression, blood clots, confusion, and dizziness. Some women also develop a condition called Ovarian Hyperstimulation Syndrome (OHSS); symptoms of this include pelvic pain, swelling of the hands and legs, stomach pain, weight gain, shortness of breath, diarrhea, vomiting/nausea, and/or urinating less than normal.) As a matter of fact I feel great and have a burst of energy that I never had before.

Before you go around mocking something do your research. Or give it a try and THEN TALK!!!!!
posted Jul 31st, 2009 7:39 am


stessie67

Thumbs Down

I must chime in here. I have not read to many negative articles on HCG but take offense at someone who clearly has not tried the diet herself. I have been batteling overweight all my life. I have had some successes but non that were permanent. I have gone through 2 rounds of HCG and i am down 39 lbs. I have never been on a regimen that was so easy or had such quick results. I plan on doing another round in September. I havent been so happy or in control of my life in over 9 years. Dont knock it till u try it i say!!!! posted Jul 30th, 2009 11:44 pm


delmem

Thumbs Down

Look elsewhere for the truth - this article is sorely lacking.

The protocol was written by Dr ATW Simeons - are you a doctor ? Didn't think so. I've WORKED with 10 physicians over the past year, not providing the diet to patients - but DOING the protocol themselves. Most can't believe it works so incredibly well, their increased energy, wondered why they'd never heard of it before. One doc in Silver Springs MD tested his metabolism and found it INCREASED on the protocol.

You're either being dishonest or you're ignorant on the topic you've decided to discuss. There IS scientific data that supports hCG for weight loss. The Lebon Study, The Asher Harper study.

Interestingly - there are 3 pharma companies - Arena, Vivus, Orexigen - with new diet drugs in clinical trials - according to the press release, the FDA's benchmarks for a "successful" test - EITHER drug group loses 5% more than placebo OR a minimum of 1/3rd of drug group loses 5% of their total body weight... the new drug trials were over an 8 month period, one just made 5%, one just over 8%.

Now - the really strange thing - those that are on the hCG protocol ON AVERAGE lose 10-14% of total body weight - not in 8 months, but in a single 30 day period. THESE RESULTS ARE TYPICAL. Many of the so called negative studies on the protocol back up this fact. (see Stein study - mean weight loss in 6 weeks 9.5%)

None of the "common" side effects you mention ARE common except headaches the first few days, not from the hCG but from the body going through a stage of detoxifying. To even mention OHSS - which is rare at 10,000 IU dosages, and if symptoms present the dose is to be cut back to 5000 IU... at 125-175 IU per day not much of a chance of that happening.

The federal government has sued people twice over the protocol for deceptive advertising - and in the first suit the governemnt in writing said they never claimed the protocol was unsafe or ineffective.

Authors Dr Weil and Dr Eades - neither promote the protocol - but BOTH have the opinion it's SAFE, one thinking it's purely placebo effect - which is incorrect, but even if it were - it's more effective than any weight loss pill or commercial diet on the market.

The problem with it - is that it's SO inexpensive, self limiting and effective - that no one could get rich on it if it because mainstream. In fact - Dr Robert Jones publically stated the FDA would never approve hCG for weight loss - because it works too well.

Over 60% of Americans are overweight - WHO was it that approved trans fats & high fructose corn syrup used in our food supply ? WHO was it that pushed the 4-4-3-2 pyramid 20 years after physicians told them it was unhealthy ? WHO has limited or removed physical activity (gym class) from school schedules do to budget restrictions? WHO approved Fen-phen for weight loss until deaths caused it to be taken off the market ? (not to mention several other drugs that have killed people over the past few decades that WERE FDA approved) Wouldn't be relying on the feds position on hCG to be a strong argument - their track record isn't that great. THEY also approve bariatric surgeries for weight loss - and current stats show 2 people in 100 die from gastric bypass surgery, over 20% have complications generally needing additional surgeries to correct. To date there is no data suggesting any serious complications from the hCG protocol, it's been used for over 50 years so one would think it would have come up by now.

The only thing your article reveals - is the need for better education. If you don't understand physiology and the amount of energy released during lipolysis to understand why this ISN'T a starvation diet, you really shouldn't post an opinion and pretend it's factual or correct. posted Jul 30th, 2009 11:41 am


zndski97

Comment

Seriously, don't knock it til you have tried it. I have not experienced any of the above side effects..I have had a great experience on the hcg...I have energy, feel beter abnout myself and have lost 20 lbs in 40 days. I did not feel like I was starving!..I drank lots of water and the hcg also pulls calories from the bad fat in your body..up to 1500 cals a day so you are not starving. So where this information came from..not sure, but it is not totally accurate. posted Jul 30th, 2009 9:57 am


amanda9999

Thumbs Down

I have been on this diet as well, losing 14 pounds in 23 days with ZERO side effects. Instead, it has taught me a new way to eat that is sustainable. I'm not sure if the author of this review actually included personal testimony as part of her research but it might give her some additional insight!
She might also want to do an article on the damage marathon runners do to their bones and joints as part of their training. It's brutal. Talk about dangerous! posted Jul 30th, 2009 9:25 am


Colleen

Comment

This is not an accurate representation of the diet. I'm on my 2nd round and have not experienced a single one of those side effects. I have great energy and the weight just falls off. Even better, during my stabilization period between rounds, I maintained it, unlike any other diet I've tried. This is the way to go if you want to make a lifetime change not just lose weight. It resets your metabolism. posted Jul 30th, 2009 8:51 am


Mags

Thumbs Down

I'm with Noltmik on this! You don't have your facts right and are making claims that you don't know from personal experience. This protocol was developed over a 20+ year period by the well-respected Dr. A.T.W. Simeons during the 1950's and has been discussed various times in The Lancet from 1954 to 1966. You can also find out about it from the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition from Sept 1959 - June 1969. There are also umpteen other reviews in medical and health journals. You need to read the protocol fully to understand how the 500 calorie diet works. It specifically burns up the abnormal fat and not the "glycogen, protein (muscle) and some fat, which lowers your resting metabolism" as you claim. It's precisely for that reason, the protocol works and re-programs the hypothalamus. Most people do not suffer any side effects at all. No hunger, no nausea, no crankiness. In fact many people feel a slight euphoria as they release the build-up of toxins from the body. I have been on this protocol since May and have lost over 32 lbs and am regaining a body to be proud of. HCG can be injected but can also be used sublingually either in it's normal form or in a homeopathic form. Thousands of people are regaining their health with this system and the diet industry is probably running scared. Because it works! posted Jul 30th, 2009 7:58 am


bonniebug

Thumbs Down

You need to get your facts straight lady, the side effects you mention are fictional. I too am a believer of hcg, I have lost 20 lbs in 3 weeks, and have unbeilivable energy, never once had a headache while on the program which is a miracle for me, stomach and digestion For me this is a miracle, the weight will never come back on. The exercise and balance diet will be longterm lifestyle for me. posted Jul 30th, 2009 12:17 am


Emily

Comment

I have been on the HCG diet for 4 weeks now. I have lost 16 lbs and I have never felt so much energy and clarity of mind. I use to wake up at 10 and drag all day. Now I get up at 6 am ready to start my day. I never dreamed that would be a possibility for me, although I have tried many times in the past. I have tried every diet I could get my hands on and for each and everyone one of them I was ALWAYS starving and would do exactly as you mentioned above GORGE! But with the injections I am not hungry at all and have a hard time eating all the food although it is stressed that I must. I am not losing as much as most do but I am happy because I am STICKING to it! I always give up and forget about it and eat everything I see and want for a long time. I am not morbidly obese but was right on the line of Obese and now I have just improved my life with the weight loss that I haven't been able to do before. posted Jul 30th, 2009 12:11 am


noltmik

Thumbs Down

I think all of your "facts" are fiction. I think the saying "Don't knock it til you've tried it" applies to this review. I think maybe talking to people that have been on the HCG diet is a good place to start. I've been in contact with over 20 people including myself that have done this protocol and not one has had any of the side effects you mention above. I lost 32 lbs 30 days and have felt great and not gained a pound since I went off the 500 calories. I don't count calories at all now and keeping it off. posted Jul 29th, 2009 11:44 pm



 

Leave Feedback

Skip the moderation queue by becoming a MyDIR member.

Already a member?

Need to sign up?
It’s free and only it takes a minute.
There are two ways to join:


Or, proceed without an account


 




module bottom

 
ss_blog_claim=eaeed692cf5e1d8dd49f5556219bc364