Diets in Review - Find the Right Diet for You

School Denies Student Right to Eat Lunch From Home

A four year old student in North Carolina was not allowed to eat the lunch her mother packed for her. Apparently her lunch was taken away from her because school officials claimed it was not healthy enough to eat based off of the USDA guidelines.

The young child brought a home-packed lunch to school containing a turkey sandwich, banana, potato chips, and an apple juice. A lunch inspector told the child she wasn’t allowed to eat it and provided her with a USDA-approved lunch. The approved lunches meet the USDA guidelines that require one serving of meat, one serving of grains, and two servings of fruit or vegetables. The uneaten lunch was returned home with the child. Inside, the girl’s mother found a note explaining that the lunch didn’t meet guidelines and a bill for $1.25, the cost of the school lunch.

The child’s mother took action. She anonymously wrote her local paper and called a state representative. The North Carolina rep contacted the school regarding the issue and the school issued an apology. The child’s lunch was deemed acceptable after a second review.

Is the fact that the meal met the guidelines the issue? The mother stated that she didn’t pack her child’s meal based off of the guidelines.
“Don’t tell my kid I’m not packing her lunchbox properly. I pack her lunchbox according to what she eats.”

Should schools have the right to enforce what children bring in their lunchboxes? My opinion is no. Especially since these school guidelines are set by the ones who say pizza is a vegetable. Furthermore, spend 5 minutes in a lunch room and see that this particular lunch that was deemed as unhealthy, is in fact one of the most balanced meals you’ll find. There’s a huge problem with the way most of our kids eat, especially in the lunchroom. Whether they are bringing food from home or buying the school lunch, most of our kids are far from getting a healthy meal.

However, if another parent wants to pack junk in the lunchbox, I support their right and do not expect the school to stop them because that means I still have the right to pack my son a truly healthy and nutritious meal.

Also Read:

School Lunches Don’t Have to be Junk

The Great Salad Bar Project to Improve School Lunches

You Can Improve School Lunches During National School Lunch Week

Childhood Obesity Drop Linked to Better School Lunches

February 15th, 2012

> Leave Feedback

User Feedback

(Page 1 of 1, 5 total comments)


This government administration needs to back off! The last time I looked, this was still a free country. 4 more years of what we currently have in office and we can start calling this country the USSR - United States of Socialist Republics!

posted Feb 24th, 2012 8:00 pm


Is this democracy?, are we living in USA, it does not seem so. when an estranger decides what is healthy for you and what your mother prepared is not good enough for you ?
soon the'll be telling us what we should think (sorry must think) or else.

posted Feb 17th, 2012 2:47 am


These are guidelines the school has too follow SERVING a child from their kitchen. The PARENT has the right to feed their child what they want. If passing by a Teacher/attentent noticed a childs lack of food then the SCHOOL may supplment (give) the child more. BUT not take what they had away. They can't make the child eat what was added.
then let the parent off the addition. WHAT WAS DONE WAS NOT RIGHT>

posted Feb 16th, 2012 4:23 pm

kendall morse

Lunch inspector? What is the original source of this?

posted Feb 16th, 2012 3:21 pm


I'm pretty sure that what happened is a violation of our 9th amendment from 1791. The rights of the people are not limited to those listed in the Bill of Rights. The govt is prevented from claiming these are the only rights people have. Also, it was a FDA inspector that told her that she had to have a school lunch, which consisted of chicken nuggets, battered and fried.

posted Feb 16th, 2012 3:17 pm


Leave Feedback

Skip the moderation queue by becoming a MyDIR member.

Already a member?

Need to sign up?
It’s free and only it takes a minute.
There are two ways to join:

Or, proceed without an account