Diets in Review - Find the Right Diet for You

Tanya Zuckerbrot’s Overhyped 10,000 Dollar Diet

Based on the idea that a high fiber diet promotes nutrition and weight loss without hunger, F-Factor seems like a reasonable diet approach. The creator of the program, Tanya Zuckerbrot, is a registered dietitian who offers her clients 10 one-on-one counseling sessions as part of F-Factor, and it’s generating a lot of buzz.

With high profile clients like former CNBC host Donny Deutsch and current Miss Universe Olivia Culpo, the F-Factor diet plan has gained notoriety in recent months as being a viable weight loss option. The catch? This program will cost you $10,000 if you want the customized version.

For that hefty price tag, clients receive those ten personal sessions as well as an in-depth consultation and education process about weight loss and nutrition. Zuckerbrot also goes over the diet plan with her clients during this initial session, reminding them about the high intake of fiber the diet requires. If clients are interested, they can pay an additional $1,500 each for a supermarket tour and refrigerator and pantry makeover. The high cost of the program begs the question of whether or not F-Factor is worth it, though.

Our resident nutrition expert and registered dietitian Mary Hartley isn’t convinced.

“Tanya Zuckerbrot is no better than other dietitians. In fact, I hear that her minions see the patients and Tanya breezes in to say a few words.”

If that is the case, clients certainly aren’t getting what they pay for. However, according to Hartley, that may not matter. “This is New York City, after all, where you can buy a t-shirt for $1 or $1,000 and you can get a haircut for $8 or $800. The quality doesn’t reflect the price,” Hartley said.

The public reaction to Zuckerbrot’s program has been mixed after articles from Yahoo! Shine and the New York Times spotlighted her this week.

Though the price may be extreme, the ideas behind the program aren’t that different from what any registered dietitian would promote.

“All RDs promote high fiber in the absence of diseases where it is contraindicated. Personally, I prefer an intuitive eating approach over a ‘program’ but programs are okay for basic education and to get people started in the right direction,” Hartley said.

Also Read:

The Manhattan Diet Contradicts Author’s Intent Spelling Diet Disaster

Lululemon Recalls its Black Luon Yoga Pant for Being Too Sheer

The Best Registered Dietitians on Twitter

Image via foxnews.com

 

March 19th, 2013

> Leave Feedback

User Feedback

(Page 1 of 1, 1 total comments)

Gerry Casanova

I respectfully wish to correct Mary's commentary about Tanya and her private practice. Clients who pay $10K only see Tanya and they have 24/7 access - they value this level of care and service.

posted Mar 20th, 2013 5:30 pm



   
 

Leave Feedback

Skip the moderation queue by becoming a MyDIR member.

Already a member?

Need to sign up?
It’s free and only it takes a minute.
There are two ways to join:


Or, proceed without an account